You pay ZERO sales tax (Except in MO)

The Mysterious Box of Mystery

A surprise selection of curated Vat19 goodies.

In Stock
Item #4235
In Stock
Item #4236
In Stock
Item #4392
Enter the quantity above and then click 'Add to Cart'


** Now shipping WORLDWIDE! **

What could possibly be nestled in this cardboard cube? There's only one way to find out—look inside!

The Mysterious Box of Mystery is a special selection of Vat19's curiously awesome products. In fact, they're even more curious than usual since you have no idea what you'll be getting!

Each box contains several different items from the shelves of Vat19's warehouse that represent some of the most awesome stuff you can buy. Each order is a surprise, and each order is a great deal since buying the contents individually would cost a lot more than getting them in this boxed bundle.

Uncover the mysterious mystery and order a Mysterious Box of Mystery today.

Please note the following:

  • We now ship the Mystery Box internationally!
  • This item cannot be returned.

Features & specs

  • Vat19-curated shipment of awesome stuff
  • You don't know what's in the box, but Vat19 does
  • A great value (always cheaper than buying the items individually)
  • Note: Each equally-priced box contains the same items
  • This item cannot be returned.
  • May contain edible items.
  • Size and shape of box may vary from what is pictured.

Watch our Mysterious Box of Mystery video

Frequently Asked Questions

We’ve answered some of the most popular questions in our video below!

Question: I want to purchase multiple Mysterious Boxes of Mystery. Will they each have the same stuff inside?

Answer: Yes, boxes of the same style will contain the same items. While we do swap out the contents occasionally (see below), it's best to assume that boxes of the same style are identical.

Question: I saw videos on YouTube and everyone got "X" in their Mysterious Box of Mystery, but I didn't get that item in my box!

Answer: If you really want a particular item, we suggest you simply purchase that item. The Mysterious Box of Mystery changes often, and it's meant to be a surprise.

We strive to ensure that the retail value of the items included in each box exceeds what you have paid for the box. The trade-off, obviously, is that you don't get to choose the contents of the box. If you'd prefer a deal without the mystery, check out our coupons.

Question: What's the difference between the Small, Large, and Mega boxes? Will I get more expensive items in the costlier boxes?

Answer: Not necessarily. A more expensive box doesn't guarantee that you'll receive more expensive items. Instead, you may find that a Large Mysterious Box of Mystery contains twice as many items that are of similar price to what is found in a Small box. However, it is possible that some Large or Mega boxes would contain higher priced items. This is all part of what makes these boxes so mysterious!

Question: What if I don't like what's in my box?

Answer: Impossible! In all seriousness, we work diligently to include a variety of popular items in each iteration of the Mysterious Box of Mystery. We're certain you'll be pleased with our choices. However, due to the pre-packed nature of this product, we cannot accept returns. Remember, surprises are fun!

Question: How often do you change the contents of the Mysterious Box of Mystery?

Answer: We pre-pack each style in small batches. As one style is close to selling out, we create new ones. We attempt to vary the contents with each new batch we create. Below is a detailed accounting of when new batches were created.

History (2018 only)

Curious when we update a box? Follow us on social media!


  • Small [#48] created
  • Large [#47] created


  • Small [#46] created


  • Small [#32,36,38,39,41] created
  • Large [#33,37,42] created
  • Mega [#31,35,40,43,44] created


  • New numbering system debuts
  • Small [#29] created
  • Large [#30] created


  • Small #69-70 created


  • Small #67-68 created
  • Large #51 created
  • Mega #40-41 created


  • Small #66 created
  • Large #50 created
  • Mega #39 created


  • Small #64-65 created
  • Large #49 created
  • Mega #37-38 created


  • Small #61-63 created
  • Large #47-48 created
  • Mega #36 created


  • Small #59-60 created
  • Large #46 created
  • Mega #35 created


  • Small #57-58 created
  • Large #43-45 created
  • Mega #32-34 created


  • Small #54-56 created
  • Large #42 created
  • Mega #29-31 created


  • Small #52, #53 created
  • Mega #28 created


Can't live without it?
Smash that 'Add to Cart' button!

In Stock
In Stock
In Stock

Burning Questions: You Ask, We Answer

Your questions that have been answered by the staff:
Sort by:   Show Only:         

Want to ask your own Burning Question?

First, please watch the video to the right. It explains the Burning Question feature and answers some common questions.

Now, if there is something that you need to know about this product that we've omitted, please send us an anonymous question and we promise to answer it within 1 business day.

Ask question:
(250 chars max)
Enter awesome:  So we know you're not spam, type "awesome".

Please excuse the shameless cross promotions!

Box of Happy Accidents

Box of Happy Accidents

A still-good collection of surprise awesomeness.

Liquid Glass Thinking Putty

Liquid Glass Thinking Putty

Transparent putty turns from clear to cloudy and back.

Shock Ball

Shock Ball

Hot potato with a shocking twist.